SAVE 25% OFF! Save 25% off EVERYTHING with orders $190+! Use code: 23SUMMERSALE25
See details
The Memorial Weekend Sale is Here! Save 25% off EVERYTHING with orders $190+! Use code: 23SUMMERSALE25
To redeem at checkout, enter code 23SUMMERSALE25 in the offer code box with any order $190+ to receive 25% off your purchase. Enter code 23SUMMERSALE20 in the offer code box with any order $160+ to receive 20% off your purchase. Enter code 23SUMMERSALE15 in the offer code box with any order $120+ to receive 15% off your purchase. Available for MSRP only. Not valid on Subscribe + Save items. Valid thru 5/31/23.
Free mini gift options! Choose your free gift with any $85+ Order. Use code: MAY23
To redeem at checkout, enter code MAY23 in the offer code box to receive a FREE mini Luminous Setting Powder, mini Hydra-Bright Pro 5 Liquid Exfoliant, mini C-Shield Eye Restore Hydrator, or Powder Puff with any $85+ order. While supplies last.
Promotions available for MSRP only. Not valid on Subscribe and Save items. Not valid on prior purchases. Offers may not be combined with any other sale, promotion, discount, code, coupon and/or offer.
The Perfect Cream Stay Shadow Stick for Each Month Revealed
Makeup, Featured

The Perfect Cream Stay Shadow Stick for Each Month Revealed

Cream Stay Shadow Sticks are without a doubt one of our favorite Fall products. They’re easy to use, convenient to travel with, last all day and come in 12 stunning shades that make the perfect base, crease and liners for the most festive season. But what about all of the other months of the year? Well, they’re just as amazing then too, which is why we’ve selected the perfect Cream Stay Shadow Stick for each month so you can rock your favorite shadow stick year round.

The Perfect Cream Stay Shadow Stick

January - Halo

platinum shimmer

It’s the beginning of the year and everything is bright and shiny; at least for a few days, until the reality of your New Year’s resolutions set in and you’re stuck in a Whole30 downfall. So enjoy the glitter and happiness as long as you can with our favorite platinum shimmer shadow.

February - Orbit

matte charcoal

Hear us out, February *may* be the month of Valentine’s Day and true love, but as a month, it’s not really that great. The weather is usually dismal and no one is actually in the mood for pink and red. So instead, try our not-quite-black charcoal shade, which can be blended out for the perfect smokey eye, whether you’re headed out on a romantic date or for drinks with friends.

March - Scotch


Copper for pennies and pennies for good luck! And we definitely got lucky with this stunning copper metallic shade. Sure, it’s a little more daring than you might be used to but if you’re looking for a way to up your neutral game, Scotch is for you.

April - Metro

metallic gunmetal

For anyone that thrives during April showers, this one’s for you. Metro is a stunning gunmetal that will give your classic spring florals an edgy vibe. Just because it’s spring doesn’t mean you have to drop everything for pastels.

May - Prelude


peach champagne shimmer

The sweetest peachy-shimmer is perfect for May flowers. No matter which way you wear Prelude, it never disappoints. You can even use it as a highlight for the high points of your face, like your nose, brow and cheek bones.

June - Beam

champagne shimmer

There’s nothing quite like the first day of Summer, it’s warm enough to enjoy a backyard BBQ but not hot enough to make you question your existence quite yet. If you’re like us, we tend to pull back on our makeup during the Summer months simply because it’s not necessary. We love Beam’s soft champagne shimmer because it brightens up the eyes and enhances your youthful Summer glow.

July - Canyon

matte clay


July is hot, hot, hot, and so is Canyon. We’re instantly reminded of sweltering heat but comforted in knowing Cream Stay Shadow Stick formulas were built to last through any conditions. Our favorite way to rock Canyon? With a monochrome, eye-cheek-lip look.

August - Keepsake


While not technically Fall, August is the unofficial end of Summer when kids start heading back to school and everyone falls back into their normal routines. This best-selling bronze is the perfect transition shade as you head into cooler months and is one of the easiest shades to wear on its own, so you have one less decision to make in the morning.

September - Echo

metallic brown

If you take out the summer from Keepsake, you’re left with Echo. A soft brown that’s almost as pretty to look at as the changing leaves, mixed with a hint of shimmer for good measure. This versatile shade is swipe-on-and-go friendly and will get you from work to your PTA meeting without missing a beat. 

October - Pitch

matte black

Let’s be honest, what other month can you attribute the color black to without being weird? Pitch is perfect for all of your Halloween needs, from a winged eye to cat whiskers. Pro tip: use Essential Cleansing Oil and a pointed Q-tip to clean up any mistakes.

November - Bonbon

matte brown

Bonbon gives us the same type of feels as Thanksgiving- happy, full and at home. When we say this is the perfect brown, we aren’t joking. It’s creamy, blendable and the perfect shade to pair with a chunky sweater for family photos.

December - Solstice

gold shimmer

No matter which holiday you celebrate in December, gold feels celebratory. We love Solstice’s intense color payoff that provides the perfect hue for your lids. Rock it with an understated lip for your work party or go big with a festive red for a soirée with friends. The possibilities are endless.

Perfect Cream Stay Shadow Stick

Which month is your perfect Cream Stay Shadow Stick shade? Tell us in the comments below!

September 9, 2019
Rewards Program

Select your FREE GIFT! ( left)